| Ashley Bell | … | Nell |
| Julia Garner | … | Gwen |
| Spencer Treat Clark | … | Chris |
| David Jensen | … | Calder |
| Tarra Riggs | … | Cecile |
| Louis Herthum | … | Louis |
| Muse Watson | … | Frank Merle |
| Erica Michelle Singleton | … | Daphne (as Erica Michelle) |
| Sharice A. Williams | … | Mo (as Sharice Angelle Williams) |
| Boyana Balta | … | Lily |
| Joe Chrest | … | Pastor |
| Raeden Greer | … | Steph |
| Judd Lormand | … | Jared |
| E. Roger Mitchell | … | Jeffrey |
| Dane Rhodes | … | Drunken Tourist (as Steven Dane Rhodes) |
| Ashlynn Ross | … | Michelle |
| Andrew Sensenig | … | Doctor |
| Diva Tyler | … | Bev |
| Marcellus Grace | … | Janitor |
| Deacon John Moore | … | Old Bluesman |
| Gideon Hodge | … | Tin Man |
| Cristina Franco | … | Marie |
| Rest of cast listed alphabetically: |
| Iris Bahr | … | Iris Reisen (archive footage) (uncredited) |
| Colby Boothman | … | Abalam / Man in the Mask (uncredited) |
| Patrick Fabian | … | Cotton Marcus (archive footage) (uncredited) |
| Adam Grimes | … | Daniel Moskowitz (archive footage) (uncredited) |
| Caleb Landry Jones | … | Caleb Sweetzer (archive footage) (uncredited) |
| Elton LeBlanc | … | Elderly Man at Apartment (uncredited) |
